Skip to main content

Who We Are

Our team is the cornerstone of our business. With experience in every phase of the real estate cycle, our team’s diligent and agile approach is trusted by real estate partners.

The Pluris Value

Our name hails from the Latin term for "great value", which embodies Pluris' mission and promise to our partners.

Passion

We care deeply, work diligently and act thoughtfully. Pluris partners trust our team of knowledgeable and determined experts to create long-term investment value.

Integrity

We strive to exceed expectations through engaged relationships. Partners depend on us to communicate decisively, attentively and transparently to create home-run outcomes.

Commitment

We’re on your team, every step of the way. Collaboration and mutual respect are cornerstones of our partnerships.

Trusted Relationships

What our partners are saying

Derek BlandHJI Supply Chain Solutions

We would like to thank Colin Underhill and the Pluris team for their outstanding service in helping us secure our most recent warehouse facility in Louisville. The Pluris Team was diligent, creative, and spent tireless hours helping us negotiate the lease and we appreciate the way that they balanced the interests of both buyer and seller.

Kari CurrieHome Buyer

It was no surprise that the Pluris team was professional, available, and knowledgeable throughout the entire process of purchasing my first home. They had immediate access and ability to work with my flexible schedule by promptly arranging showings and providing honest opinions when needed. I would recommend Pluris to any home-buyer.

JD RothbergWild Eggs Restauranteur

The Pluris team has executed flawlessly on getting my business in the right locations and for the right price. I would highly recommend!

Kelly BryantHome Buyer And Seller

The residential team does an awesome job, and I would highly recommend Pluris. Not only have they helped us buy our home, but they have helped many of our friends. Pluris really works hard for their clients, which is what it takes in this market!

Condrad DanielsHJI Supply Chain Solutions

Partnering with the Pluris team to help scale our geographical footprint has been one of the best decisions HJI Supply Chain Solutions has made.

Our People

No matter the market, no matter the obstacle, it's our people who drive business forward.

President

J. Colin Underhill

Colin is the President and Co-Founder of Pluris Real Estate. He has a strong passion for quality and an impressive track record of executing highly-acclaimed development projects. Colin began his real estate career in 2004 in the property management sector before evolving his skills as a developer, construction manager, and broker.

In 2008, he saw an opportunity to utilize his experience to build a platform which provided an avenue for individuals to invest in real estate, which ultimately became Pluris. This paved the way to not only assist developers and tenants, but also individuals looking for alternative investment strategies. Colin has acted as a property manager, development director, broker, and private equity leader in creating winning outcomes for over $800,000,000 in real estate projects, including condominium developments, multifamily investments and rehabs, commercial office buildings, residential subdivisions, and commercial retail projects. The wide array of project types and skill sets allows Colin to lead Pluris in a most unique manner.

Colin received his Bachelor’s Degree in Finance from the University of Georgia, where he was on the Men’s swim team and served as team captain his senior year. Colin and his wife, Natalie, have 5 amazing children who help foster a very active lifestyle both professionally and personally.

CFO

Matt Willinger

Matt is the CFO and Co-Founder of Pluris Real Estate. With an extensive background in all financial aspects of real estate, Matt spearheads the financial modeling and due diligence of acquisitions, along with overseeing the financial performance of all Pluris’ investment funds.

After graduating with degrees in Finance, as well as Decision Sciences and Information Systems from the University of Kentucky, Matt began his career at Cummins, Inc. (NYSE: CMI). In only two years, he was able to climb from an analyst position to corporate financial manager. After gaining experience in a large corporation, Matt pursued his passion for real estate. Matt’s ability to identify unique investment opportunities ultimately propelled him to a position as CFO for a boutique development firm.

In 2008, Matt completed his MBA at Bellarmine University and also obtained his CPA license. He was able to do this while managing over $100M in active developments and over $750M in asset values in the multi-family, office, retail, and residential sectors of real estate.

VP of Brokerage and Development

Austin Gutgsell

Austin is the VP of Brokerage at Pluris Real Estate. He began his real estate career working with Stirling Properties, a leading developer in the Gulf South region. He worked on several facets of the development process, including the financial analysis of large retail, office, and medical developments. Upon moving to Louisville, Austin worked as a commercial agent in the brokerage division of NTS Development Company, which leases and manages nearly 4 million square feet in the Louisville MSA. He gained experience working to create marketing packages, compile market reports, conduct financial analysis for project feasibility, and assisting in all aspects of the lease negotiation process. Austin’s experience in multiple aspects of the real estate life cycle provides value-add services for his clients.

Prior to starting his real estate career, Austin was a former LSU Golfer and NCAA Academic All-American. While at LSU, he was able to assist in bringing the Tigers back to the National Championship after a 15-year drought. As a senior, he was named Co-Captain and helped the Class of 2012 become what was then the winningest class in school history. Gutgsell has also been recognized as Golfweek’s NCAA National Player of the Week and the SEC Player of the Week, for winning multiple individual titles.

After his undergraduate degree, he attended the LSU Flores MBA Program, where he graduated number one in his class with a 4.0 GPA. Gutgsell was voted to the list of LSU’s All-Time Student-Athlete Academic Dream Team, which recognized fifty individuals who have achieved the highest level of academic excellence and/or made major contributions to their communities.

VP of Finance and Strategy

Karsen Thornton

Karsen Thornton joined Pluris Real Estate in 2021 as a member of the Commercial Real Estate team. With a background in Finance and Accounting, Karsen is involved in the financial aspects of the business, including transaction and firm accounting, financial modeling, due diligence aspects.

In addition to working with Pluris, Karsen is a local Business Broker with Murphy Business and Financial Services. She advises business owners through the sale process and conducts professional business valuations across a variety of industries. Karsen graduated from the University of Kentucky with degrees in Accounting and Management. She obtained her CPA license while in public accounting and completed her MBA at the University of Louisville while working full-time in Accounting, Finance, and Mergers and Acquisitions at Humana.

Outside of the office, Karsen runs a team of ~75 volunteers at GRRAND, a Louisville-based dog rescue, and is a Pure Barre instructor. She lives in Louisville with her husband, Clay, and their two dogs, Moose and Birdie.

Commercial Brokerage Specialist

Jon Grell

Jon joined Pluris Real Estate in 2020 as a commercial brokerage specialist. Since 2017, he has worked in the real estate industry with a focus on sales and leasing activity in the Louisville, KY MSA. Jon has a strong background in retail and office asset classes.

Prior to his career in real estate, Jon worked for Cutting Tools Inc. where he was in sales for over 10 years. He graduated from Indiana University with a degree in social science by way of Saint Xavier High school. Jon is also an assistant coach with the Saint Xavier soccer program which one of the most successful, and winningest, high school soccer programs in the country.

In his free time he enjoys playing soccer, tennis, and golf, traveling the world, and spending time with his family and friends. Jon has a passion for selling and investing in real estate, a strong work ethic, and competitive spirit.

Director of Marketing

Caitlyn Hacker

Caitlyn joined Pluris Real Estate in 2021 as the Director of Marketing. She believes that creating meaningful relationships while continuing to grow and learn are the most important things in life. Caitlyn is an enthusiastic, creative, and motivated young professional who is eager to learn more about the real estate business.

Caitlyn graduated from the University of Louisville with her Bachelor of Science in Business Administration, Marketing. As the Director of Marketing, Caitlyn taps into all facets of the company. Her main efforts involve content creation across all social media channels, developing and executing marketing materials for both commercial and residential agents, and other office/administration pursuits. When Caitlyn is not in the office, you can find her spending time with her friends and family, planning her next trip to NYC, or learning about the latest social media and fashion trends.

Residential Specialist

Meredith Denbow

Meredith Denbow is a real estate veteran with more than a decade of experience in residential sales and multi-family leasing and management. Meredith shares her passion for real estate with several members of her family. Her father is an established developer in Louisville, KY and a few of her brothers currently work for prominent real estate firms in Los Angeles, CA. A native Louisvillian, Meredith is a graduate of the University of Louisville with a Bachelor’s Degree in Finance.

Since 2007, she has built an unrivaled reputation for creating successful outcomes for her clients. Meredith recently oversaw marketing, leasing, and resident relations at Germantown Mill Lofts, a fully-occupied, award-winning restoration of the former mill factory in the chic, up-and-coming Germantown neighborhood. All the while, Meredith has bought and sold numerous single-family homes for her clients across the Louisville MSA. She is high-energy, detail oriented, and passionately pursues the perfect fit for her buyers and sellers alike. Meredith lives in Northfield along with her husband, Pat, and her three active young sons, Sebastian, Oscar, and Felix.

Residential Specialist

Jordan King

Jordan has grown up in the real estate arena, giving her the unique opportunity to gain knowledge in development, property management, and commercial/residential leasing. More recently she has risen as one of the top producers for single family residences, with a unique expertise in condominium sales. Jordan attended Wake Forest University where she received her bachelor’s degree in Finance.
Residential Specialist

Channing Flaherty

Channing is a real estate professional for Pluris Real Estate; she truly can do anything to help create successful outcomes for all clients. As a Louisville native, Channing grew up surrounded by residential and commercial real estate transactions through her family’s real estate business. Channing launched her real estate career in May of 2010 after graduating with a degree in Marketing from the Terry Business College at the University of Georgia in Athens, GA. During her time at the University of Georgia, Channing was a very successful leasing agent for Fairfield Properties. In addition, Channing was a CREW (Commercial Real Estate Women) scholar and was accepted into a highly competitive internship program with CB Richard Ellis during the summer of 2009 where she worked for three months in their Washington, DC office.

Channing’s expertise is in relationship development and executing exceptional communication with clients. She is extremely involved in the Louisville community, which has helped create a successful track record for herself and her clients in the market. She is actively involved with Holy Trinity Catholic Parish serving on their Parish Council as well as leading their Young Adult Ministry. She is also a former member of the Sacred Heart Alumni Board and an active volunteer with Maryhurst Charities.